Jump to content
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Pope Benedict Resigning


add

Recommended Posts

Ash Wednesday

I have a feeling Benny must know something we don't. It must be between him and God right now.

 


Indeed, there's so much that we really don't know, it would do us all well to keep that in mind and pray for the entire situation.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

carmenchristi

I'm not attacking or turning on the Pope. I'm saying his quitting is a bad idea and will hurt the Church. I hope I'm wrong. You can disagree with something your parents or kids do without hating them.


Look up pope Celestine V..... He resigned from the papacy and is a canonized saint. I think it is a harsh judgement to call BXVI a quitter. This is a testimony of courage and humility. Can you imagine how difficult such a resignation must have been! I firmly believe that it is wrong of anyone who would presume to determine the correctness of such a decision. It is a matter of conscience. Our Holy Father loves the Church and is clearly (by what he has said) doing this for her benefit.

I have lived serious scandals through the behavior of members of the hierarchy, and would be the first to disagree with a decision made in order to save face. This is not one of those situations.

Exposing oneself to universal critique, ridicule, judgement and the like is not an act of cowardice, it is a following in the footsteps of Christ!
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Look up pope Celestine V..... He resigned from the papacy and is a canonized saint. I think it is a harsh judgement to call BXVI a quitter. This is a testimony of courage and humility. Can you imagine how difficult such a resignation must have been! I firmly believe that it is wrong of anyone who would presume to determine the correctness of such a decision. It is a matter of conscience. Our Holy Father loves the Church and is clearly (by what he has said) doing this for her benefit.

I have lived serious scandals through the behavior of members of the hierarchy, and would be the first to disagree with a decision made in order to save face. This is not one of those situations.

Exposing oneself to universal critique, ridicule, judgement and the like is not an act of cowardice, it is a following in the footsteps of Christ!

 


well said. p.s. i'm stealing this.

Edited by Lil Red
Link to comment
Share on other sites

carmenchristi

"Pope John Paul II remained in office so that he might show us how to suffer and how to die. Pope Benedict XVI is leaving the Papal Office so that he might show us how to live in humble honesty."



This!
Link to comment
Share on other sites

FutureCarmeliteClaire

I don't think that he would have resigned without really good reason, and I don't think it's anybody's place to dig further than what he has already said.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, euthanasia supporters are probably happy. If you're old and infirm, it's okay to give up.

I fight every day to physically get out of bed. I've had such a bad head injury that I get sundowners. If you don't know what that is, google it. There are times I stop in the middle of conversations because I can't come up with a word. Maybe I should just give up and stay in bed. I don't because I've been given the gift of life, so I'm going to live it.

The Apostles didn't give up. Popes aren't supposed to either. Don't you think when you are elected Pope you know it is for life? Maybe we should make marriage vows until we get too tired or infirm. So what if he can't travel overseas. He can do his job without working 18 hour days. If he needs help to walk down the aisle, what's wrong with accepting help?

I'm not a traditionalist. I didn't like many of the things he did. Yet, I think he should stay. I'm too upset about this to even debate it any further.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, euthanasia supporters are probably happy. If you're old and infirm, it's okay to give up.

I fight every day to physically get out of bed. I've had such a bad head injury that I get sundowners. If you don't know what that is, google it. There are times I stop in the middle of conversations because I can't come up with a word. Maybe I should just give up and stay in bed. I don't because I've been given the gift of life, so I'm going to live it.

The Apostles didn't give up. Popes aren't supposed to either. Don't you think when you are elected Pope you know it is for life? Maybe we should make marriage vows until we get too tired or infirm. So what if he can't travel overseas. He can do his job without working 18 hour days. If he needs help to walk down the aisle, what's wrong with accepting help?

I'm not a traditionalist. I didn't like many of the things he did. Yet, I think he should stay. I'm too upset about this to even debate it any further.

I agree.  I think it sets a bad precedent, and I say that as someone who has all sorts of medical problems, but I simply refuse to give up.

Edited by Apotheoun
Link to comment
Share on other sites

You live long enough, you get to see all kinds of unexpected things, don't you?

 

The last pope to resign was Gregory the Something-or-Other, when the Avignon papacy split came to an end. I don't know a lot about it, but I know that Catherine of Siena was involved in resolving that mess, so Catherine of Siena will be my daily prayer partner until a new pope is elected.

 

Gregory XII

Before that there was Pope St Celestine V and apparently there were others before that

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Gregory XII

Before that there was Pope St Celestine V and apparently there were others before that

I believe there was a papal resignation in the 11th century too, but there were scandals surrounding that episode and the pope who resigned ended up becoming pope again.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

carmenchristi

At this moment I am as close as I am allowed to get to the tomb of Peter. Please join spiritually in this pilgrimage and pray for our Holy Father, his successor and the universal Church.

Edited by carmenchristi
Link to comment
Share on other sites

PhuturePriest

Being the Pope is different than being a parent. Being a Priest is different than being a parent. That is why they retire eventually. If Priests that have one or two parishes retire because it gets to be too much, what do you think being the Pope is like? He's unable to do his job adequately. If you are mad, take it up with God. Pope Benedict didn't choose to get older, but it happens and he is no longer able to do his job efficiently. He recognizes that Catholicism needs to be on the forefront at all times in this age, and if he's lying in his bed all day waiting to die, he cannot do this. He is taking an ACT OF HUMILITY, not an act of cowardice and giving up. I'm sure he's grieving over this far more than you are. It's not an easy decision to make, and he deserves our support, not our abandonment.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Priestly retirement is a modern practice.  Clerics did not retire in the ancient Church.

 

The Church is dynamic as well as steadfast. Celibacy is also a "modern practice."

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...