Jump to content
An Old School Catholic Message Board

"whi I Murdered 13 American Soldiers At Ft. Hood"


Starets

Recommended Posts

Why do you feel that courts must involve a monopoly power?


Why do you feel that multiple courts issuing contradictory rulings with no clear way to pay for themselves will work?
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Why do you feel that multiple courts issuing contradictory rulings with no clear way to pay for themselves will work?

 

Do you think the current system doesn't involve multiple courts and contradictory rulings?

 

I don't see payment being an issue, since countless businesses operate without resorting to violence. I don't know why having no recourse to aggression would be a problem. Have you ever heard of the Law Merchant?

Edited by Winchester
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Do you think the current system doesn't contradict?

I did actually. Which court has equal authority to the Supreme Court in the USA?

I don't see payment being an issue, since countless businesses operate without resorting to violence. I don't know why having no recourse to aggression would be a problem. Have you ever heard of the Law Merchant?

Who will pay for it? If I don't have the money for my cable bill, they turn it off. If I don't have the money to pay the Winchester Court(just to use an example) how do I get my justice?
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I did actually. Which court has equal authority to the Supreme Court in the USA?

Who will pay for it? If I don't have the money for my cable bill, they turn it off. If I don't have the money to pay the Winchester Court(just to use an example) how do I get my justice?

Excellent example of a monopoly power abusing authority granted by contract. You're aware that rulings are overruled, right? That's a contradiction, isn't it? Of course, you're only looking at one part of the world. Are you arguing that we should have a one world government, or are you fine with the  current existence of multiple courts.

 

Charity, mutual aid organizations, pro bono, contingency, perhaps? I can imagine any number of ways people might handle this. Are you arguing that your concerns justify aggression? Are you in fact making a utilitarian appeal justifying the state?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Excellent example of a monopoly power abusing authority granted by contract. You're aware that rulings are overruled, right? That's a contradiction, isn't it? Of course, you're only looking at one part of the world. Are you arguing that we should have a one world government, or are you fine with the current existence of multiple courts.

Multiple courts exist for multiple societies. Are you denying that there would be multiple courts in a single anarchist society?

I fail to see why a single court with the ability to over rule all other courts within a society is a contradiction of anything.

Charity, mutual aid organizations, pro bono, contingency, perhaps? I can imagine any number of ways people might handle this. Are you arguing that your concerns justify aggression? Are you in fact making a utilitarian appeal justifying the state?

Conservatives have been telling the poor to rely on charity to pay their bills for years. Might as well change it to "floop you" as it gets the same reaction. Edited by Vitamin
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Multiple courts exist for multiple societies. Are you denying that there would be multiple courts in a single anarchist society?

I fail to see why a single court with the ability to over rule all other courts within a society is a contradiction of anything.

Conservatives have been telling the poor to rely on charity to pay their bills for years. Might as well change it to "floop you" as it gets the same reaction

What do you see as the purpose of courts? I see it as a means of settling disputes. Sometimes these disputes involve torts, sometimes they're merely a business matter. I thus see no problem with there being more than one third party that people seek out to settle their disputes. This actually already occurs. 

 

Do you believe that supreme court decisions can never be overturned? 

 

I personally know lawyers who work pro bono cases. Do you know what "contingency" means in reference to hiring a lawyer? Do you know what a mutual aid society is?

 

 

Currently, what happens if someone doesn't have the money to prove property confiscated through civil asset forfeiture is innocent? There's no hurry on answering this. I just want you to educate yourself on the matter.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The words I say have special meanings that only I know of.

That is literally the #1 PM fallback.

literally.gif


The idea that institutions would exist in an anarchic society is fairly constant in the anarchist literature going back at Lear to the 19th century.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...